23rd April 2025

Is the Job Spec Obsolete?

Charlotte Dean

Charlotte Dean

HR Director

Is the Job Spec Obsolete?

The employment landscape is almost unrecognisable from that of twenty years ago. A new generation of millennial workers and continuously developing technology have redefined the way in which we search and apply for jobs. As a result, recruitment and HR teams have adapted their methods for attracting and hiring potential candidates, meaning many traditional recruiting practices are now obsolete. So what’s on the way out? One of the very first things that a potential candidate will see: the job spec.

While job specifications may still play a small, obligatory role in searching for a job, when it comes down to finding the right candidate the individual comes first and the role itself comes second. Of course, certain roles do require specific qualifications and skills, but we are now in a working world in which an employer’s brand and its people are its biggest assets.

With that in mind, ensuring that an individual is the right fit for a business must come before the potential candidate’s qualifications, experience or anything else that sits in the job specification. This has become one of the most influential aspects of recruiting. Hiring an individual who just simply is not a good fit for the business could have disastrous results; a lack of unity and harmonious sense of teamwork in the workplace will have an adverse effect on the work being produced and staff morale, which ultimately runs the risk of being filtered down to clients and customers.

Choosing to hire a candidate with more experience than an individual with the right personality could be a costly mistake for businesses, with the price tag attached to replacing a member of staff around £30,614 per employee according to Oxford Economics. This is why HR and recruiting teams are increasingly disregarding CVs to ensure they make the right hire first time. Tailoring interview questions to get a true glimpse of the candidate’s attitude and enthusiasm is just one approach to this, forgetting the traditional and monotonous questions such as “What’s your biggest weakness?” and instead asking more considered questions such as "Tell me about the relationships you've had with the people you've worked with. How would you describe the best ones? The worst?”

While certain skills on a candidate’s CV can bring practical benefits to a job role, personality, drive and style of communication can bring much more. Long gone are the days when a candidate is turned away for not having enough years’ experience, as employers seek to get to know the individual instead of what they have summarised on paper.

How we can help you

If you’d like to discuss any of the issues detailed in this blog, get in touch with us today on 0161 941 2426. We’re here to help.

Book a no obligation consultation today

What our clients say

"Truly excellent HR service and support"

The support, knowledge and guidance that Katie and the team at P3 provide to the business has proven truly invaluable. They really do become your right hand for everything HR. Although outsourced, the service and support provided is truly embedded into the business to become a key part of the business and the team, both for myself and our employees. Thank you P3PM!

L Carter

"Expert Support & Terrific Service"

Our company joined with P3 a few years ago and we have experienced nothing but expert support with all our HR needs. Michaela has been a fantastic asset, acting almost as if she is part of the company with her quick replies and excellent reports that allow us to monitor our companies needs more efficiently. We would also like to mention Katie, Emma, Claire and Charlotte who have helped us develop and improve our policies and procedures as well as providing specialist support to us with regards to the more delicate and less desirable sides of managing employees. P3 have become an invaluable asset to our company supporting us as we continually develop and adapt our HR needs.

Luke McDuff

"Working Alongside P3PM"

Having P3PM support is an asset to our company. When I need any assistance with certain circumstances P3 is always available and always very helpful. They are a brilliant team and were very helpful during the latest disciplinary we had on site.

Graham

"P3 - a Value Add team"

I have worked with P3, and more specifically Claire, for over 6 years. Claire is a great sounding board and provides advice and guidance on a range of HR activities from day-to-day operations through to strategic initiatives, that allows the organisation to continually develop and create a high performing workforce. On a personal level, P3 also provide opportunities for myself and my team to learn and develop which is a invaluable service to us all.

Katie Yates

"Engaging with P3 People"

I have engaged with P3 People over the past three years and it has been a real pleasure working with them and it has enabled me to grow the company as I wanted to by developing our culture and ensuring that we were recruiting, developing and retaining some great people. As with most businesses, we did have a few people issues to deal with and at those times I really appreciated that P3 People were there advising us and guiding us through the various procedures that we had to follow. Also, one of the most helpful things they did for us was to help us put our performance review process in place. We ran it for the first time in March-April last year and it went down very well with a positive response from the staff.
As our company has grown significantly now, we have recently recruited our own HR Director. However, I should emphasise that because of the help that P3 People provided, it allowed me to take the company to where we are today and I have no hesitation in recommending P3 People for the work that they do and the support that they have provided to us.

Alan Boyd

Subscribe to our newsletter

For the latest news, offers and events, sign up to our newsletter.

Book a Free HR Advice Call

We’re here to help. Talk to us in confidence about your people challenges and requirements. Click to arrange a complimentary call with one of our HR Consultants.

0161 941 2426 Or